Ineffective parenting styles fall into two categories:
<ul>
<li>Helicopter parents: Control children through rules, demands and micromanaging</li>
<li>Permissive parents: Give freedom without limits, responsibilities or consequences</li>
<li>Neither approach teaches decision-making skills</li>
<li>Both styles create dependency in different ways</li>
<li>Children from both struggle with real-world challenges</li>
</ul>
The helicopter approach creates compliant children who collapse without external control. The permissive approach creates entitled children who expect others to solve their problems. Neither prepares children for responsible adulthood.

Two Parenting Styles to Avoid

Empathy before consequences preserves the parent-child relationship:
<ul>
<li>Empathy first defuses defensive reactions</li>
<li>Delayed consequences allow for thoughtful responses</li>
<li>Calm delivery increases learning opportunity</li>
<li>Shared problem-solving builds responsibility</li>
<li>Maintaining connection while enforcing limits</li>
</ul>
This sequence works because children learn best when emotionally regulated. Empathy shows you care about the child, not just the behavior. The delay allows both parent and child to respond thoughtfully rather than reactively, preserving the relationship while still providing necessary boundaries.

Empathy First, Consequences Second

Natural consequences teach through real-world outcomes rather than parent-imposed punishments:<ul><li>Children experience the direct results of their choices</li><li>Parents express empathy without rescuing or punishing</li><li>Small failures in childhood create resilience</li><li>Problem-solving skills develop through necessity</li><li>Responsibility transfers from parent to child</li></ul>This approach works because consequences teach what words cannot. When allowed to experience manageable problems, children develop the thinking skills required for adult life. This differs from punishment, which teaches children to focus on avoiding parental anger rather than making wise choices.

Natural Consequences

The best gift we can give our children is to allow them to learn from the consequences of their own behavior.

Give your children all the choices you can live with, not the ones you can't.

Children learn responsible behavior when they're actually given responsibility.

The four steps to responsibility create capability through gradual transfer:<ul><li>Step 1: Assign tasks appropriate to the child's age</li><li>Step 2: Model completion of these tasks yourself</li><li>Step 3: Allow the child to help you with the tasks</li><li>Step 4: Transfer full responsibility with appropriate oversight</li></ul>This progression works because it provides scaffolding for new skills before requiring independent execution. Children learn through observation, participation, and gradually increased responsibility. This creates competence and confidence simultaneously, preventing both learned helplessness and overwhelming expectations.

The Four Steps to Responsibility

Choices within limits develop decision-making skills while maintaining boundaries:
<ul>
<li>Small, controlled choices build decision-making muscles</li>
<li>Limited options ensure all outcomes are acceptable</li>
<li>Time limits prevent stalling tactics</li>
<li>Natural consequences follow poor choices</li>
<li>Power struggles diminish significantly</li>
</ul>
This approach works because it satisfies children's developmental need for autonomy while respecting parents' responsibility for safety and values. By controlling the choices offered rather than the child, parents create win-win situations that develop responsibility while maintaining necessary boundaries.

Choices Within Limits

The consultant parent guides rather than directs, especially with teens:<ul><li>Asks questions instead of giving answers</li><li>Offers perspective without demanding compliance</li><li>Shares experience rather than commanding</li><li>Respects autonomy while providing guidance</li><li>Maintains influence through relationship not control</li></ul>This approach works because teenagers developmentally need to establish independence while still requiring guidance. By switching from director to consultant, parents maintain influence during a phase when control becomes counterproductive. This preserves the relationship while still providing valuable adult wisdom.

The Consultant Parent

Empowering builds capability while enabling creates dependency:
<ul>
<li>Empowerment allows struggles that build strength</li>
<li>Enabling prevents necessary growth experiences</li>
<li>Rescued children develop learned helplessness</li>
<li>Empowered children develop problem-solving skills</li>
<li>Appropriate challenges build confidence and competence</li>
</ul>
This distinction explains why well-intentioned helping often creates dependent, entitled children. When parents provide too much support, they inadvertently communicate that their child is incapable of handling age-appropriate challenges. True help comes through guided struggle, not removal of obstacles.

Empowering vs. Enabling

Shared thinking teaches problem-solving through guided collaboration:<ul><li>Parents think aloud about real decisions</li><li>Children participate in age-appropriate ways</li><li>Questions guide rather than lectures</li><li>Process matters more than specific outcomes</li><li>Financial, social, and family considerations become visible</li></ul>This approach prepares children for adult decision-making by making the thinking process visible. Rather than simply announcing decisions, parents involve children in appropriate aspects of the reasoning, helping them develop critical thinking skills through observation and guided participation.

Shared Thinking

Enforceable statements communicate boundaries you can personally enforce:<ul><li>Focus on what you control, not what you wish the child would do</li><li>State what you will do, not what the child must do</li><li>Deliver calmly without threats or warnings</li><li>Follow through consistently when tested</li><li>Eliminate power struggles by removing the fight</li></ul>This approach works because it shifts from unenforceable demands to statements of personal boundaries. Instead of trying to control the child (impossible), you control your own actions in response to the child's choices. This places responsibility where it belongs—with the child.

Enforceable Statements

Thinking words engage children's reasoning while fighting words create opposition:<ul><li>Questions engage the brain's problem-solving circuits</li><li>Statements and demands activate defensive circuits</li><li>What, how, and where questions promote thinking</li><li>Why questions often increase defensiveness</li><li>Children own solutions they discover themselves</li></ul>This approach works because genuine questions activate different neural pathways than commands or criticism. When children must think through situations, they develop neurons and connections that commands short-circuit. Solutions they generate themselves create both ownership and more effective learning.

Thinking Words vs. Fighting Words

Tired of endless power struggles with your kids? This revolutionary parenting approach shows how to end the cycle of nagging, threatening, and punishing. Foster Cline and Jim Fay demonstrate how allowing children to make mistakes—and experience natural consequences—builds responsibility and decision-making skills. By replacing control with guided choices, you'll prepare kids for the real world while maintaining a loving relationship. Perfect for parents frustrated with both permissive and authoritarian approaches, this practical guide offers specific techniques that work from toddlers through teens.

A time-tested parenting book with over 900,000 copies sold! Now updated to address technology use, screen time, and social media. Designed for preschool and beyond, this helpful and practical psychology-based parenting method is an invaluable guide for all parents! Teach your children healthy responsibility and encourage their character growth from a young age. Learn to establish healthy boundaries with your children through easy-to-implement steps without anger, threats, nagging, or power struggles. Trusted by generations of parents, counselors, and teachers to lovingly raise responsible children, Parenting with Love and Logic includes solutions for dozens of specific topics such as:<ul><li>Tantrums</li><li>Managing screen time</li><li>Grades and report cards</li><li>Chores</li><li>Getting ready for school</li><li>Peer pressure</li><li>Cyberbullying</li><li>Navigating crisis situations and grief</li><li>And much more!</li></ul>Each issue is indexed for easy reference. Learn how to tame tempers and re-establish a calm, healthy relationship and positive communication with your child today! “This is as close to an owner’s manual for parents as you will find. Now, parents can embrace mistakes as wonderful learning opportunities to raise respectful, responsible, and caring children.” —Gloria Sherman, MA, MED, LPC, cofounder, Parenting Partnership “I have been delighted to share the powerful yet simple wisdom of Jim Fay and Foster Cline with my counseling clients. The principles in Parenting with Love and Logic are practical, proven techniques that keep parents on track to raising responsible, loving, confident children.” —Carol R. Cole, PhD, LMFT “Parenting with Love and Logic is a terrific book for parents that provides important concepts and practical solutions to help children become emotionally, socially, and morally healthy.” —Terry M. Levy, PhD, codirector of Evergreen Psychotherapy Center; coauthor of Attachment, Trauma, and Healing “Parenting with Love and Logic is an essential component for our schools, parents, and teachers. Thousands of families have been positively impacted by the love and logic principles.” —Leonard R. Rezmierski, PhD, superintendent support administrator, Wayne RESA

FOSTER CLINE AND JIM FAY

Similar ideas to Foster Cline and Jim Fay

Invisible bond of love

Empathy First, Consequences Second

Clarity of responsibility